Cellaring Cheese


One of my goals this year was to start to get my feet wet at making cheese. I failed. I have not made cheese.

But what has happened is a very happy thing: I’ve become good friends with cheesemaker  Holly Gale and have had the opportunity to help their farm in a variety of ways – in exchange for cheese. All of these cheeses were made by Holly, and are being aged by me [with Holly's consultation] in my cellar. I’m learning that aging cheese can be a dynamic affair, and here are some photos from my first washing [done between sausage-making projects on Sunday... it was a busy Sunday], and follow-ups a couple days later.

Goat Tomme on the left after a couple weeks in my cellar, after 3-4 months of age from Holly’s aging room. Since it arrived in my cellar it developed a white coat, underlain by browny orange, and soft orangy blotches atop it all. Young goat tomme on the right – I received this one at 2 days old, and all that fuzz developed in my cellar. Note the wire racking, atop water. They were rusting, so Holly hooked me up with the cheese matting you see in the other pictures.

The aged tomme post-wash [wiped with new cloth & 2% salt brine]. Check out that color!!! The cheese aging setup had such optimal conditions – currently 12C and 90+% humidity – that I decided to commit some of my soft cheeses to the same conditions to further mature them. 3 St. Maure in center, 2 Valencay on the right. Holly was having a hard time with dry conditions, so the bloomy rind hadn’t taken over atop the ash on the Valencay like it should. So these soft cheeses went from the wrapper in the fridge, to here.  You can see that the wire rack is gone, and I now have a paver about 1″ thick on the bottom, under the matting. It’s got salted water like a moat around the masonry. A lid goes atop this all, opened ajar to bring down humidity as required.

The young tomme post-wash. Holly says it’s looking good, so presumably all those blotchy molds are friendly, desirable molds. Whites, blues, browns, rust-colored, different shapes, patterns, patches – this cheese is pretty dynamic. I have to admit that it’s still counter-intuitive to be embracing, even encouraging mold formation on food – I certainly grew up in a different era/paradigm. But it is indeed exciting – feels a bit like playing with fire. Yummy smelling fire though.

The aged tomme and soft cheeses – 2 days later. I washed Sunday morning, and this was Tuesday morning. I am shocked how quickly the white molds developed [check the Valencays 2 photos above - they're mostly black 2 days earlier]. I had hoped they would get their white-mold on, but thought it would take more time than that. These soft cheeses are destined for some research on how maturity impacts flavor and texture, although I’m also on watch [on Holly's advice] to watch that they don’t mature too quickly, or they get runny under the rind.

The young tomme, 2 days post-wash. Already getting quite the dynamic blotch pattern with some white skiff of mold. Looks friendlier than before. I suppose that it’s worth noting that the milk was inoculated with mold cultures prior to cheesemaking – so there is some predictability as to what molds may dominate, etc, but the specific color palette and nuance of flavor will be driven by the microflora and conditions in my cellar. Very exciting stuff.

Aging cheese, for me, right now, is worth the maintenance if for no other reason than smelling their glory when I go down there. It smells BEAUTIFUL. It will also be a dream-come-true to head down to the cellar to grab fresh, mature, dynamic, funky cheese rather than reaching for the fridge – which stunts the growth and is too cold and too dry for them to do their thing.

Still a cheese newbie – but workin’ on it.

12 Responses

  1. Mel says:

    Lovely cheeses, your cellar must really smell like a true cellar now! Those Valencays are a little alarming though, that white mold doesn’t look as friendly as the stuff on the Tomme, to me anyway. It looks like some form of yeast, but that’s just pure speculation on my part. Hopefully they don’t end up too runny because of it. (Though that’s not necessarily a bad thing – I tasted the runny Valencay and while it was extremely funky, it was still perfectly edible. Just not in large quantities.)

  2. Mel – My understanding is that Holly uses a combo of penicillium candidum and geotrichum candidum for the bloomy white rinds. I’m impressed though – I looked it up here [] and they indicate that Geo15 [which I know Holly does use] has a “yeast-like form”. I’m surprised you picked up on that.

  3. Barry says:

    Awesome stuff Kevin, nicely done.

    Just a side note, remember that yeasts are still fungi, and thus are similar to the “molds” you are talking about here. Most “true” molds are filamentous fungi but every now and again, based on environmental conditions and available nutrients, filamentous fungi can undergo a morphogenic shift to a yeast-like form. Similarly, yeasts can also become filamentous forms of fungi for similar reasons.

    Pretty fascinating stuff if you think about it actually. I love this in particular because I am a fungal biologist and love being able to do microbiology at home. As of yet I have not ventured into the cheese realm but man it sure would be a lot of fun.

  4. Barry – wow am I glad you do what you do. Don’t be shocked if you get the odd email from me about this. Thanks for weighing in!

  5. Barry says:

    Kevin – Anytime, glad to help or answer any questions.

  6. [...] pretty pleased. Perhaps a bit cold, but I’ll take it. I’m fairly certain that the cheese cellaring setups are contributing critical additional moisture to the space as they have water wicking into [...]

  7. Incredible experience. Your project has definitely been one that is perfect for both of you. I can see how enamoured you are and would be exactly the same, in your shoes. I seek learning experiences like that because there is such a intrinsic desire within to provide one’s own sustenance. There is no better feeling, for me, than when I prepare everything for my little family from scratch from everything I have made myself. Cheese making has most definitely been goal of mine. However, I have not ventured into it yet. But, I absolutely will. Incredible learning an appreciation here, Kevin. Can you hear me cheering you on?

  8. Kevin says:

    Valerie – Holly wants to teach others. I’ll leave that with you.
    Thanks for the encouragement!

  9. [...] and one her ‘Farmer’s’. You can see what they looked like nearly two months ago here. Every time I handle theses cheeses it brings me immense joy, not only because of the soft, [...]

  10. [...] originally intended exclusively for wine, it is now sharing half the space with dry cured meats and cheese aging setups – two items that I discovered happily enjoy similar environments. With some ingenuity, [...]

  11. [...] I gave them some of my time helping their business, Holly hooked me up with some wheels of goat’s cheese to cellar. This is the wheel of Tomme I acquired in early [...]

  12. [...] but carries a complex, old-world cellar flavor from the dry cure”.The St. Maure is one of the cheeses from Smoky Valley Goat Cheese that Kevin has aged in his temperature [...]

Leave a Reply

4 × five =